Manufacturing Automation: ROI Calculator Checklist

Manufacturing automation can save money, improve efficiency, and enhance workplace safety. But how do you know if it’s worth the investment? This guide helps you calculate ROI for automation projects, breaking it into clear steps and metrics.

Key Takeaways:

Labor Savings: Automation reduces labor costs by up to 75%, saving $15–$20/hour.
Efficiency Gains: Processes run 20–110% faster with automation.
Safety Benefits: Fewer injuries, saving billions annually in related costs.
Initial Costs: Equipment, software, setup, and training costs are essential to consider.
Energy and Material Savings: Reduce energy use by up to 30% and minimize waste.

Quick ROI Steps:

Calculate upfront costs (equipment, software, setup, and training).
Estimate savings (labor, energy, materials, and quality improvements).
Project long-term gains (production speed, output, and flexibility).
Use tools to compare costs vs. benefits over time.

Automation isn’t just about cutting costs - it’s about smarter, safer, and faster manufacturing. Use this checklist to make informed decisions and maximize your investment.

How To Calculate ROI In Automation

Initial Investment Costs

Understanding upfront costs is essential for accurate ROI projections and effective budgeting.

Equipment Costs

Automation starts with investing in hardware. When planning an equipment budget, include the following:

Cost Component	Details
Hardware Purchase	Expenses for robots, sensors, and control systems
Delivery & Freight	Charges based on size and shipping distance
Sales Tax	Varies by state regulations in the U.S.
Extended Warranties	Additional coverage for key components
Insurance	Typically a percentage of the equipment's value

"Equipment Costs means total expenses tied to acquiring, setting up, and financing equipment, including unavoidable related costs."

After hardware, software costs play a critical role in enabling these systems.

Software Costs

Automation systems depend heavily on software to operate efficiently. Key software-related expenses include:

Control System Software and Integration Platforms: For programming and ensuring system connectivity
Data Analytics and Performance Monitoring Tools
Annual Licensing Fees: Ongoing costs for maintenance and updates

On average, annual maintenance costs for software range between 15–20% of the initial development budget.

Integration costs are another factor to consider when calculating initial expenses.

Setup Costs

The system integrator market is expected to grow from $27 billion in 2022 to $35.5 billion by 2027. Setup costs typically range from $15,000 to $200,000, depending on the complexity of the project.

"A robot is a new process that's being added into a manufacturing facility. In order for that to be successful, we need to take into account the people aspects as well as the technology aspects." - Mark Barglof, owner Kinetic Technologies

Additional setup costs may involve adapting facilities to accommodate safety barriers, floor space requirements, and integration with existing systems.

Training Costs

Employee training is crucial for successful automation. In 2021, companies spent an average of $1,280 per employee on workplace learning, with individual training programs costing between $5,000 and $10,000 per employee.

"Training should be regarded as an investment rather than a cost – there should be a clear ROI expectation set at the start, so [it's] known the benefit of the return outweighs the initial investment." - Shaun Thomson, CEO, Sandler Training

Companies with strong training programs see measurable benefits, including 218% higher income per employee and 24% greater profits. The average cost per hour of training is $103, covering areas like:

Operator and maintenance certification
Programming and troubleshooting
Safety protocols
System administration

Well-executed training improves operational performance and accelerates ROI.

Cost Reduction Analysis

Labor Savings

Automation can significantly cut labor expenses. Automated systems operate between 20% and 110% faster than manual processes, leading to substantial savings. Here's how to calculate labor savings:

Cost Component	Calculation Method
Manual Labor Cost	Number of operators × Annual salary per operator
Post-Automation Cost	25% of current labor costs
Net Labor Savings	Current costs – Automated costs

"With tasks being completed faster, it's no wonder robotic automation can significantly reduce global workforce costs. These savings come largely from the fact that programming and maintenance costs are lower than training and maintaining operators."

Example: A manufacturing facility invested $150,000 in automation, including a $50,000 robot running three shifts. Their annual labor costs dropped from $300,000 to $75,000, saving $225,000 in the first year.

These savings play a key role in evaluating your overall ROI.

Energy Savings

Modern automation systems are designed to save energy, with features that can cut energy consumption by up to 30%. For instance, CITIC Pacific Special Steel reported:

15% increase in output
11% decrease in energy consumption

Some effective energy-saving strategies include:

Monitoring energy use per unit
Tracking equipment utilization
Setting data-driven thresholds
Automating shutdowns
Scheduling energy-heavy operations during off-peak hours

Automation also reduces material waste, further adding to cost efficiency.

Material Savings

Automated systems excel at minimizing material waste through precise control and real-time monitoring. Research from the University of Virginia highlights that automated inspection systems can achieve up to 99.9% accuracy.

Quality Control Savings

Better quality control is another key cost-saving area. Advanced automation has shown impressive results:

A car seat manufacturer cut defect rates by 30% using AI inspection.
An AI-based casting inspection platform reached 99.86% accuracy.
Companies like Audi and Ford reported fewer defects thanks to AI-driven quality control.

"ROI of an Automated Quality Control System can be evaluated by verifying the trend of Cost of Poor Quality. One has the choice of either live with the issues and pay the cost by dealing with cost of poor quality which can lead to loss of business too... or implement Automated Quality Control System and eliminate such risks." - Rupesh Kumar, General Manager - Head Operations - Transmission components and E-Mobility

Cost benefits of improved quality control include:

Reduced scrap and rework
Fewer warranty claims
Lower return rates
Enhanced brand reputation
Higher customer satisfaction

These improvements directly impact ROI, making automation a smart investment.

sbb-itb-ce80a9d

Production Improvements

Boosting production efficiency is a key factor in justifying the return on investment (ROI) for automation.

Output Increases

Automation can drive production increases of up to 5.1% in its early stages.

For example, Avalign Technologies, a medical device manufacturer, reported a 25–30% improvement in Overall Equipment Effectiveness (OEE). They added capacity without purchasing new equipment and resolved bottlenecks by implementing automated shop floor monitoring.

Key metrics to track output improvements include:

Metric	Description	Impact on ROI
Production Volume	Units produced per time period	Boosts revenue
OEE	Equipment availability × performance × quality	Improves efficiency
TEEP	Utilization of maximum production time	Optimizes capacity
Utilization Rate	Actual vs. available production time	Increases resource use

Higher output also leads to shorter cycle times, enhancing productivity.

Speed Improvements

Between 2015 and 2025, robot-performed tasks grew by 30–45%. Reducing cycle time - the time it takes to produce a single unit - by 25% can unlock extra capacity and elevate productivity.

To achieve faster production speeds:

Analyze and validate processes before automation.
Prioritize automating critical bottlenecks.
Assign skilled workers to oversee systems.
Schedule preventive maintenance to avoid downtime.

Quality Consistency

As production speeds up and output grows, maintaining consistent quality becomes even more essential for sustaining ROI. In 2018, 52% of manufacturing workers collaborated with automation and AI systems, resulting in noticeable quality improvements. Combining human expertise with automated precision delivers:

Reliable product specifications with minimal variability.
Lower chances of human error.
Improved worker safety and retention.

Production Flexibility

Automation today offers unmatched adaptability. Several leading companies demonstrate how flexible automation can transform production:

Canon: Integrated robots, machine vision, and AI for efficient electronics manufacturing.
Nike: Partnered with automation firms to accelerate production timelines.
Medtronic: Scaled ventilator output during COVID-19 using flexible automation.
L'Oréal: Utilized collaborative robots and digital twins for versatile manufacturing.

To enhance flexibility:

Incorporate mobile workstations.
Use shared components and practical safety measures.
Implement predictive maintenance systems.

These advancements allow businesses to respond quickly to market shifts and customer needs while maintaining high-quality standards, directly influencing ROI.

Maintenance Requirements

Maintenance plays a key role in improving ROI by reducing downtime and extending the lifespan of equipment. Studies reveal that factories lose between 5% and 20% of their productive capacity during downtime, with unplanned downtime costing as much as $260,000 per hour. Including proper maintenance practices in your ROI calculations ensures both costs and savings are accurately accounted for.

Regular Maintenance

Mechanical system upkeep is crucial, as 45% of unplanned downtime stems from equipment failures. Key tasks for maintaining mechanical systems include:

Component	Maintenance Task
Moving Parts	Lubrication and inspection
Belts & Chains	Tension checks
Bearings	Inspection and replacement
Alignment	Balance and alignment checks

Predictive maintenance, as demonstrated by LLumin's CMMS, can cut downtime by up to 90% and drastically reduce equipment breakdowns.

Software Maintenance

Keeping software up to date is vital for protecting automation systems from security threats and performance problems. Best practices include:

Scheduling updates during planned downtime
Maintaining system backups
Testing updates in a controlled environment before deployment
Documenting all system changes

Technical Support

Human error accounts for 23% of unplanned downtime. Effective technical support can help mitigate this risk. Key strategies include:

On-site Support
Regular training and cross-training programs equip operators with the knowledge to handle machine mechanics and preventive maintenance.
Remote Assistance
Remote diagnostics help reduce response times and lower support costs.
Emergency Response
Clear protocols for handling critical failures, including defined response times and escalation procedures, ensure swift action during emergencies.

Parts and Supplies

Managing inventory strategically is essential to avoid delays caused by missing parts while avoiding overstocking. As dataPARC explains, "Downtime is any duration in which a process is not running". To keep operations smooth:

Track the Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF) for crucial components.
Maintain minimum stock levels based on supplier lead times.
Build relationships with dependable suppliers for urgent deliveries.

ROI Calculator Guide

This guide helps you turn cost and savings data into clear financial insights for better decision-making.

Required Data Points

To calculate ROI for manufacturing automation, gather these key data points:

Category	Required Data Points
Baseline Performance	Current OEE, machine running costs per hour, and annual operating hours
Investment Costs	Hardware purchase prices, software licensing fees, and installation/setup expenses
Production Metrics	Annual turnover, variable cost ratio, and current output capacity
Expected Improvements	Projected OEE increase percentage and anticipated cost reductions

ROI Calculation Steps

Use your current operational data to follow these steps:

Establish Current Baseline
Record your existing performance metrics, such as OEE, production costs, and output levels. For instance, Evocon's research shows facilities with a 60% baseline OEE can achieve notable gains.
Calculate Total Investment
Add up all costs, including hardware, software, and implementation. Don’t forget to account for recurring expenses like annual software licenses.
Project Returns
Estimate the benefits by comparing current operational costs with projected improvements. Include both direct savings and productivity boosts.

Once you've completed these steps, choose a time frame that matches your investment goals.

Time Period Selection

Pick a time frame based on your priorities:

Short-term Analysis: Look at periods from 6 months to 1 year for immediate results.
Medium-term Planning: Use a 1-3 year range for a balanced evaluation.
Long-term Vision: Opt for 5 years or more to assess strategic investments.

Understanding Results

ROI calculations give you a clearer picture of your investment's impact. For example, Evocon highlights a case where a company with a 60% baseline OEE achieved a 1,735% ROI in the first year by improving OEE by 15%.

To interpret your results effectively:

Positive vs. Negative Returns: A positive ROI means your returns are higher than your costs.
Comparative Analysis: Use annualized ROI to weigh different investment options.
Implementation Timeline: Some facilities start seeing benefits in as little as 4 months.

These insights can guide your decisions and help prioritize investments.

Making Investment Decisions

Main Points Review

When analyzing automation investments, it's essential to pair your ROI calculations with a review of these critical factors. Accurate data is the backbone of a solid ROI assessment.

Factor	Impact Assessment
Direct Savings	Includes reductions in labor costs, material waste, and energy use
Safety Benefits	Fewer workplace injuries (industry cost: $167B in 2021)
Process Optimization	Boosts in production capacity and product quality
Long-term Value	Considers maintenance needs and technical support

These factors build on the insights from the ROI Calculator Guide, helping you make well-rounded decisions about automation investments.

Action Steps

Focus on resolving broader operational challenges, not just improving individual machines.
Work with experienced integrators who have a track record of on-time delivery.
Assess equipment costs alongside potential savings in labor, processes, production, and safety.
Choose integration partners based on:
- Their reputation and years in the industry
- A portfolio of completed projects similar to your needs
- Performance and quality metrics
- Alignment with your company’s values and goals

ROI calculations should be seen as adaptable tools to help you explore automation solutions that align with your business objectives.